TopSurveys
EarnStar
Our rating
9.2/10
8.8/10
Avg. earnings per hour
3.5$ per hour
2.5$ per hour
Minimum payout threshold
5$
5$
Payout speed
Instant to 3 business days
Instant to 2 business days
Has mobile app?
Yes
Yes
AppStore rating
4.7/5 Stars
4.7/5 Stars
Trustpilot rating
4.2/5 Stars
4/5 Stars
Trustpilot reviews count
5701 total
3452 total
Launched in
2024
2024
Quick verdict — which one should you choose?
TopSurveys edges out EarnStar for users who want a dedicated, survey-first experience. Its standout feature is an exceptionally low disqualification rate — you spend more time earning and less time getting screened out. TopSurveys is the better pick if you prefer focused survey work with consistent payouts and minimal frustration. EarnStar is the smarter choice if you want variety — its game-based earning opportunities can pay significantly more per task, especially through milestone rewards. Both platforms share the same $5 payout threshold and fast processing times. You genuinely can't go wrong with either, but for pure survey earnings, TopSurveys delivers the more reliable and streamlined experience in 2026.
TopSurveys edges out EarnStar for users who want a dedicated, survey-first experience. Its standout feature is an exceptionally low disqualification rate — you spend more time earning and less time getting screened out. TopSurveys is the better pick if you prefer focused survey work with consistent payouts and minimal frustration. EarnStar is the smarter choice if you want variety — its game-based earning opportunities can pay significantly more per task, especially through milestone rewards. Both platforms share the same $5 payout threshold and fast processing times. You genuinely can't go wrong with either, but for pure survey earnings, TopSurveys delivers the more reliable and streamlined experience in 2026.
Earnings potential compared
TopSurveys and EarnStar take different approaches to earning, which makes a direct comparison interesting. TopSurveys focuses squarely on paid surveys, averaging around $1.00 per completed survey with most taking 5 to 15 minutes. That translates to roughly $3 to $4 per hour of focused survey work. The platform's biggest advantage is its survey-matching algorithm — fewer screening questions and dramatically lower disqualification rates mean more of your time converts to actual earnings.
EarnStar casts a wider net. Surveys pay between $0.50 and $1.50, but games are where the real money lives — milestone-based game rewards can reach $100 or more per offer. For surveys alone, expect to earn $2 to $4 per hour, comparable to TopSurveys. But combining surveys with game offers can push daily earnings considerably higher for active users willing to invest the time.
Both platforms share a $5 minimum payout threshold (after an initial $20 first withdrawal). TopSurveys processes payouts within 30 minutes to 72 hours, while EarnStar boasts near-instant PayPal payouts — often within 5 minutes. EarnStar also offers more payout options including Venmo and a wider range of gift cards. TopSurveys counters with fee-free withdrawals and a reliable $5 referral bonus.
Metric | TopSurveys | EarnStar |
|---|---|---|
Avg $/hour | $3.00–$4.00 | $2.00–$4.00 |
Survey frequency | 15–20/day | 10–15/day |
Bonus program | Yes | Yes (level bonuses) |
Referral bonus | $5 | Varies |
User experience and interface
Both TopSurveys and EarnStar offer quick, hassle-free sign-up processes that take under two minutes. TopSurveys presents a clean, survey-focused interface with a well-designed mobile app on both iOS and Android. Its survey-matching system is the standout — pre-qualifying you with minimal screening questions results in one of the lowest disqualification rates in the industry. This alone makes the day-to-day experience noticeably smoother than most competitors.
EarnStar features a modern, polished interface with a gamified feel that suits its mixed survey-and-gaming model. The app is well-rated at 4.4 stars on Google Play with over 100,000 downloads. Survey disqualification rates are more typical of the industry — some users report being screened out after several minutes, though the platform mitigates frustration by offering game-based earning as a fallback.
Customer support is solid on both platforms. TopSurveys holds a 4.2/5 Trustpilot rating from thousands of reviews, while EarnStar sits at 4.0/5. Both apps are responsive to user feedback and regularly push updates to improve the experience.
Full verdict on TopSurveys vs EarnStar
TopSurveys wins this head-to-head for anyone whose primary goal is earning from surveys. Its industry-leading low disqualification rate means you spend more time completing surveys and less time getting screened out — a genuine quality-of-life improvement that translates directly into higher effective earnings. Combined with fee-free payouts, a proven $5 referral program, availability in 40+ countries, and consistently high survey volume, TopSurveys is the more dependable survey platform. EarnStar brings something different to the table — its game-based earning model can yield higher individual payouts, and near-instant PayPal withdrawals are hard to beat.
The honest truth is you can't go wrong with either platform, and using both simultaneously is a smart strategy. But if you're choosing one to start with, TopSurveys is the recommendation for most users. Its focused, survey-first approach delivers the most consistent and frustration-free earning experience. Sign up, complete your profile, and you could reach your first payout within a day. EarnStar makes an excellent companion app — especially if you enjoy mobile gaming alongside your survey routine.
Frequently asked questions
Is TopSurveys or EarnStar better for beginners?
TopSurveys is the better starting point for beginners. Its straightforward, survey-only focus means there's no learning curve — sign up, answer surveys, get paid. The low disqualification rate is especially valuable for new users who might otherwise get discouraged by constant screen-outs. EarnStar is also beginner-friendly, but its mixed model of surveys, games, and offers takes slightly more time to navigate effectively.
Which pays more, TopSurveys or EarnStar?
For surveys specifically, both platforms pay similarly at $2 to $4 per hour. TopSurveys has a slight edge because lower disqualification rates mean more completed surveys per hour. However, EarnStar can pay significantly more overall if you combine surveys with high-value game offers, where individual milestone rewards can reach $100 or more.
Can you use both TopSurveys and EarnStar at the same time?
Absolutely, and it's actually the recommended strategy. Both platforms source surveys from different providers, so you'll have access to a much larger pool of opportunities by using them together. Many experienced survey-takers run both apps side by side.
Which has faster payouts, TopSurveys or EarnStar?
EarnStar has the edge on raw payout speed — PayPal withdrawals often arrive within 5 minutes. TopSurveys processes rewards within 30 minutes to 72 hours. Both platforms share a $5 minimum threshold (after an initial $20 first withdrawal). TopSurveys withdrawals are completely fee-free, while EarnStar offers more payout options including Venmo and a wider selection of gift cards.
About
Delivering independent journalism, thought-provoking insights, and trustworthy reporting to keep you informed, inspired, and engaged with the world every day.
Featured Posts
Explore Topics
View other comparisons
